The failed court case of illegal hunting of a Eurasian Collared-dove [1] in Gozo during the spring hunting season of 2022 is “symptomatic of the state of enforcement and justice on the island,” BirdLife Malta said.
It stated that the news about the acquittal of a Gozitan hunter by Judge Consuelo Scerri Herrera on appeal is “disappointing, but is after all a symptom of the state of enforcement and prosecution on hunting the island of Gozo sees, especially during consecutive spring hunting seasons.”
The case, BirdLife Malta said, “goes back to the spring hunting season of 2022, and was the only illegality reported for the island for the whole spring hunting season, and only brought to justice thanks to the intervention of BirdLife Malta staff and volunteers who caught the incident on video.”
No other illegalities were acted on or brought to justice by police for the duration of the entire hunting season as confirmed by Government’s own reporting to the European Commission, the NGO said.
BirdLife Malta explained that the case revolves around a sentence given to the hunter by Magistrate Leonard Caruana earlier last year, “after BirdLife Malta identified the suspect, recounted the video evidence collected on the day, and even presented an examination of the evidence that had clearly shown the hunter killed a protected Eurasian Collared-dove and not a European Turtle-dove which was huntable at the time.”
At the time, after chasing the bird, the hunter had been accused of then “finishing it off using his mouth.”
The NGO argued that the evidence “brought forward professionally in court was suitable enough for the Magistrate to find the hunter guilty of the charges brought forward by Gozo Police.”
It added that, “such assistance to the law courts provided by BirdLife Malta was not welcomed by defence lawyer Deborah Camilleri, who is also the wife of Minister for hunting, planning and Gozo, Clint Camilleri.”
BirdLife Malta stated that, “Camilleri, in her submissions in the appeal case, has belittled the input provided by BirdLife Malta, drawing comparison to the lack of scrutiny of evidence and the case provided by Gozo Police and the Wild Birds Regulation Unit (WBRU), that also falls under the same Gozo Minister.”
The NGO said that “while the conclusion by the judge rests on the manner in which the court case was handled, the video evidence showing the Collared Dove being killed was not disputed.”
BirdLife Malta went on to say that “the end result is one where a hunter who has committed a crime during a spring hunting derogation is acquitted as a result of a lack of capacity and professionalism in bringing such court cases forward diligently, allowing the defence to find all possible loopholes to conclude the case in the hunter’s favour.”
BirdLife concluded by saying that “with the European Commission currently pursuing an infringement case on the lack of enforcement of hunting and trapping regulations, and the clear lack of enforcement during spring hunting seasons, the systemic cracks especially on the island of Gozo cannot be more clear.”
Photo: BirdLife Malta