- Gozo News - https://gozo.news -

Health Minister “endangering lives of GGH patients on transfers to Mater Dei” – MUMN

Health Minister "endangering lives of GGH patients on transfers to Mater Dei" - MUMNThe Malta Union of Midwives and Nurses has warned that “the Health Minister’s inaction is endangering lives of patients in the Gozo General Hospital – the Ministry’s continued failure to act is placing patients in Gozo at serious and unacceptable risk.”

In a statement on Monday, the union argued that “at the Gozo General Hospital (GGH), patient safety is clearly not a priority for Health Minister Joe Etienne Abela, when critically ill patients are being transferred to Mater Dei Hospital (MDH).”

MUMN claimed that “critically ill patients who are routinely certified for transfer, are accompanied by a nurse only, deliberately ensuring that no doctor from GGH is required to take responsibility during the transfer.”

It stated that “in a recent case, nurses identified a patient as being in a serious critical condition. Despite this, the Medical Director still certified the transfer to be carried out with nurse-only accompaniment, completely disregarding the nurses’ professional assessment and the risks involved. Initially it was identified that an Anaesthetist should accompany the patient. Then it was ping-ponged to a doctor and finally to the nurse only.”

The MUMN went on to highlight that “tn another alarming case – involving a critically ill relative of the Health Minister himself – doctors at GGH again refused to accompany the patient. Only after intense managerial and political pressure was exerted, did a doctor eventually agree to accompany the patient, resulting in a 12-hour delay in transfer. This incident exposes what is already widely known, including by GGH management: doctors at GGH consistently resist to accompany patients to MDH.”

The union noted that “the nurses’ concerns in this case were tragically validated when, upon arrival at MDH, the patient had to be immediately intubated due to an obstructed airway. Nurses were right. Patient safety had been ignored.”

It pointed out that “while the Health Minister appears quick to drag nurses before the courts, a clear and disturbing two-tier system exists when doctors jeopardise patient safety.”

“All nurses at GGH have expressed grave concern about this long-standing and dangerous practice,” stated MUMN. “Transferring critically ill patients with nurse-only accompaniment is not only unsafe – it is reckless. Worse still, when something goes wrong, it is the nurse who pays the price. In the event of a patient’s death during transfer, magistrates are called in, the nurse is investigated, suspended, and faces the very real risk of losing their job and the professional warrant.”

The Union added that “this must be contrasted with the case of Fino at SVP, where doctors allowed a dementia patient – known to be a wanderer- to remain in an open ward instead of a closed one. Despite this fatal failure, and with the full backing of the Ministry, the doctors involved faced no legal consequences whatsoever. As reported in the Times of Malta, the Health Minister publicly stated that “misdiagnosis is not a crime,” effectively confirming that doctors enjoy immunity even when fatal errors occur.”

The union said that nurses at GGH have therefore “completely lost trust in the Health Minister’s ability – or willingness – to protect them. The SVP case sent a clear message: doctors are shielded from accountability, while nurses are publicly scapegoated and politically targeted.”

It insisted that “unlike doctors, nurses are exposed on all fronts. Legal action against nurses may be initiated not only by the Health Division but also by patients’ relatives, as demonstrated in the Karin Grech Hospital choking case.”

The MUMN stressed that this crisis in GGH, affects not only ITU and CCU nurses but also nurses working in the Emergency and Admissions Department, who are equally exposed to risk.

“It is now evident that both GGH management and the Health Minister are more concerned with keeping the medical profession comfortable than with protecting patients or safeguarding nurses from financial ruin and loss of professional warrant,” said the union.

According to the union, “the current Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) at GGH – drafted by doctors – was never formally approved by GGH management and was intentionally not developed in consultation with MUMN, despite nurses being the primary stakeholders affected.”

This SOP should never have been authored by the Medical Director. It should have been developed transparently by GGH management in consultation with MUMN, given its serious legal consequences for nurses – consequences that appear to be of no concern to those who drafted it.

MUMN therefore calls on the Health Minister to stop gambling with the lives of Gozitan patients and to take immediate, decisive action at GGH to ensure safe patient transfers to MDH.

Unfortunately, in Malta, as clearly demonstrated by the Fino case, action is often taken only after someone dies. MUMN said it has repeatedly raised warnings – all of which have been ignored.

“We warn clearly and publicly: do not wait for a death during patient transfer to act,” it said.

MUMN concluded by saying that it will be also requesting an urgent meeting with the Ministry for Health since this situation cannot be allowed to prevail.

File photo: Gozo News

[1] [2] [3]