- Gozo News - https://gozo.news -

Din l-Art Helwa’s landmark Court victory: Grade 1 protection is absolute

Din l-Art Helwa has secured a significant legal victory for Malta’s cultural heritage after the Court of Appeal upheld the organisation’s appeal and revoked a permit for a development on the historic Cottonera fortifications, ruling that even minor alterations to the appearance of Grade 1 scheduled sites are prohibited.

DLH said that the case concerned planning application PA/1012/24, which authorised the construction of a 250 square meter structure for ancillary facilities to a sports ground and an underground reservoir. The development was approved on the Grade 1 scheduled glacis adjoining the Cottonera Lines, an area presently forming part of the San Klement Park in Zabbar.

Aside from forming an integral part of the Grade 1 scheduled fortifications, the site is also located Outside the Development Zone, within an Urban Conservation Area and an Area of High Landscape Value, DLH said.

The organisations said that in its Judgement delivered on the 16th November, the Court unequivocally confirmed that the protection afforded to Grade 1 scheduled sites is ”not merely a presumption against development, but an absolute prohibition against alterations which change their external or internal appearance.”

DLH added that the Environment and Planning Review Tribunal had previously dismissed the organisation’s arguments, reasoning that the development’s visual impact was limited, that its height had been reduced, and that the Superintendence of Cultural Heritage had raised no objection to the revised plans.

Through its Judgement, the Court of Appeal decisively rejected the Tribunal’s proposition that such considerations can override the clear prohibition contained in the applicable planning policy.

Din l-Art Helwa said that it considers this ruling an important affirmation of the legal safeguards protecting Malta’s most significant historic monuments and scheduled sites.

“This Judgement confirms that Grade 1 scheduling carries real legal consequences. It cannot be reduced to a designation whose restrictions may be relaxed through subjective assessments of visual impact, architectural treatment or the perceived benefits of a development.”

Din l-Art Helwa called upon the Planning Authority and the Environment and Planning Review Tribunal to give full effect to this Judgement when determining applications affecting Grade 1 scheduled sites.

The organisation said it will continue to defend Malta’s architectural, historical and environmental heritage and to challenge decisions which undermine the safeguards established for its protection.

Din l-Art Helwa was represented by Dr Claire Bonello and Perit Tara Cassar.

Photo: DLH

[1] [2] [3]