Repubblika has welcomed remarks made by President George Vella a few days ago that the process of Constitutional Reform [1] must not be limited to the interests of the two Parliamentary political parties but must include broad participation including that of civil society.
In a statement, Repubblika said that it is concerned that the first steps in the process “do not appear to meet this objective.”
It pointed out that the invitation to the public to submit “suggestions”on how the Constitution should change appears to be extremely limited in scope.”
“Submissions are made on a separate, individual basis and no one is aware what anyone else has submitted,” stated Repubblika. “As far as we can tell political parties will then filter these submissions retaining those that serve their interest and discarding the rest.”
It argued that the Constitution is intended to “limit the power of governors and therefore the governors themselves are completely unsuitable decision makers on how their own powers should be restricted.”
Repubblika reiterated that “we find no comfort in the participation in this process of the President.”
“In spite of his undoubted good intentions, such participation amounts to exceeding the limits of his powers and responsibilities within the Constitutional bounds that define his role today. That is hardly an encouraging start to a process that is supposed to redefine those limits” it added.
“Irrespective of whatever moral authority President George Vella might hope to have, the government has repeatedly demonstrated its determination to use its unhindered control of Parliament to implement Constitutional changes that serve its own interests.”
Repubblika stated that “the fact that the government is recruiting a State Attorney this summer that will be appointed at the sole and exclusive discretion of the Prime Minister as a result of Constitutional changes that were not discussed with anyone outside Parliament, indicates that the process launched by President George Vella could very well be a front behind which political parties implement the changes that best suit their interests.”
“We are deeply concerned that our detailed submission on the process of Constitutional review and reform, handed in to President Marie Louise Coleiro Preca last March on her own request and of the Steering Committee of the two political parties, has not even been acknowledged,” said Repubblika.
“Nor have we been given any sort of acknowledgement by President George Vella since his swearing in.”
Repubblika stated that it does “not presume to have some right to determine the process of change of the Constitution.”
” But we have the responsibility to inform the public of our concerns that behind-closed-doors Constitutional reforms have, in universal historical experience, led to compromised democracy, restraint on human rights and the exculpation of tyranny under the guise of high sounding but unenforceable principles,” it added.
Repubblika said that it has today again submitted its recommendations for a “transparent, genuinely inclusive and participatory Constitutional reform process as part of the formal call for suggestions launched by President George Vella a few days ago.”
It reiterated “that failing proper public participation, and notwithstanding our wishes for a genuine improvement to our Constitutional framework, our stand is firmly against any changes to the Constitution.”
Repubblika concluded by saying that it would much rather continue to enjoy the protections given by “our present imperfect Constitution than trust our fate to a future, unknown re-written constitution designed to protect instead the whims of the political parties who currently abuse those safeguards.”