HIA is required for every development with World Heritage Site boundaries – Coalition for Gozo
Email item
| Print item
|
|
The Coalition for Gozo said it has taken note of the recent statement issued by the Superintendence of Cultural Heritage (SCH), in which it dismissed suggestions that a Heritage Impact Assessment (HIA) is required for every development within World Heritage Site boundaries.
In a statement, the Coalition for Gozo said that it wishes to “remind the Superintendent, Mr Kurt Farrugia, of what the Director of the UNESCO World Heritage Centre, Mr Lazare Eloundou Assomo, wrote to the Ambassador to UNESCO Mgr Vella Gauci on 3 October 2022 regarding the Gigantija Heights apartment block” proposed within the UNESCO Ggantija Buffer Zone:
“In accordance with the Operational Guidelines, I am enclosing this information (Annexes I-VI) to enable the World Heritage Centre to verify its contents and seek their comments. I would like to reiterate that, again in accordance with the Operational Guidelines, an HIA should be carried out as a pre-requisite for development projects and activities that are planned for implementation within or around a World Heritage property, and that such assessments should serve to identify potential negative impacts on the Outstanding Universal Value of the property and to recommend mitigation measures against degradation or other negative impacts on the cultural heritage within the property or its wider setting.”
The Coalition for Gozo argued that “the UNESCO Director could not have been more explicit or unequivocal in his position.”
“We further remind the Superintendent that he and his office had originally endorsed the construction of the Gigantija Heights apartment building within the designated UNESCO Buffer Zone and only metres away from the Ggantija Temples. On that basis, the Planning Authority granted the development permit,” said the Coalition.
“It was for this reason that the Coalition for Gozo submitted a formal request, under Article 80 of the Development Planning Act (2016), for the revocation of that permit (at a subnational cost). The request was upheld, and the permit was indeed revoked,” it said.
The Coalition for Gozo pointed out that the newly proposed large apartment block along Triq Tal-Qacca (PA/07453/24), situated within the UNESCO Buffer Zone and in close proximity to the burial site of the Ggantija Temple builders at the Xaghra Circle, is therefore required to be subject to a Heritage Impact Assessment, precisely as Director Lazare Eloundou Assomo stated: “an Coalition for Gozo HIA should be carried out as a pre-requisite for development projects and activities that are planned for implementation within or around a World Heritage property…”
“Grave concern is being expressed regarding the conduct of the Superintendence of Cultural Heritage in relation to development within the UNESCO buffer zone,” stated the Coalition for Gozo.
The Coalition noted that “the public justifiably asks – How can the very authority entrusted with protecting our cultural landscape be permitting, supporting, or defending large-scale construction that visibly damages it?”
It stressed that “the UNESCO buffer zone exists to prevent exactly this kind of intrusion. Allowing such developments not only undermines the integrity of the historic setting, but also erodes confidence in the national institutions tasked with safeguarding our heritage.”
“The Superintendence of Cultural Heritage is reminded that its mandate is to protect, not to enable the gradual destruction and visual dilution of our historic environment,” stated the Coalition for Gozo.
It concluded by calling upon the Superintendence “to explain its position, to account for its decisions, and to urgently realign its actions with its legal and cultural responsibilities.”
The statement was signed by:
Din l-Art Helwa (Ghawdex); Ghawdix and Wirt Ghawdex.
Photos: Coalition for Gozo


























