European Commission calls on Malta to discontinue finch trapping practices
Email item
| Print item
|
|
The European Commission has today decided to send a reasoned opinion to Malta for failing to comply with the Birds Directive and calls on Malta ”to stop authorising finch trapping.”
The Directive aims to protect birds and their habitats across the EU, as well as halting the decline or disappearance of birds’ species. ‘
The EC said that finch trapping can be allowed exclusively under strict derogation rules. In 2018 the Court of Justice of the European Union had condemned Maltese yearly recreational finch trapping derogations and in 2024 the Court of Justice had also condemned the finch trapping derogations launched for alleged ‘research’ purposes since 2020, as they both breached the Birds Directive.
The EC said that ”nevertheless, Malta adopted new finch trapping derogations for the 2024, 2025 and 2026 autumn seasons, similar to the one annulled by the Court in case C-23/23. Moreover, in 2025, Malta adopted amendments to its legislative framework to relax enforcement and reduce the involvement of scientists from the European Union for Bird Ringing in the implementation of the research derogations.”
The Commission sent a letter of formal notice to Malta in November 2025.
Today’s reasoned opinion challenges the Maltese finch trapping research derogations and aims to address aspects not covered by the ruling of the Court in case C-23/23.
”The Commission maintains that the derogation adopted by Malta does not pursue a genuine research purpose and instead inappropriately uses the research derogation for continued recreational hunting despite previous Court rulings,” it said.
In addition, the EC said that ”Malta fails to demonstrate other satisfactory solutions and does not ensure appropriate enforcement.”
The Commission said it is therefore sending a reasoned opinion to Malta, which now has two months to respond and address the shortcomings raised by the Commission.
In the absence of a satisfactory response, the Commission said that it ”may decide to refer Malta to the Court of Justice of the European Union.”
Ministry for Gozo Response
The Ministry for Gozo has responded to today’s European Commission Reasoned Opinion concerning the ”research derogation” relating to the seven species of wild finches.
The Ministry said that following the judgement delivered by the Court of Justice of the European Union on the 19th of September 2024 in Case C-23/23, ”the Government introduced a number of legislative amendments with a view to addressing the findings of the Court. These amendments included further justifications regarding the absence of other satisfactory solutions.”
The Ministry went on to say that ”despite these efforts, the Commission has proceeded with infringement proceedings initiated on the 21st of November 2025 and has now issued a Reasoned Opinion, raising concerns as to whether the derogation, under the revised legislative framework, genuinely pursues a research purpose.”
”The Government takes note of this Reasoned Opinion and remains committed to the ongoing constructive dialogue with the European Commission. The Government now has two months to respond to the Reasoned Opinion,” the Ministry said.
The Ministry for Gozo concluded by saying that the Government ”remains committed to defending the research derogation, whilst ensuring full compliance with European Union law and protecting the cultural identity and traditions of the Maltese and Gozitan people.”
File photo: BirdLife Malta Finch cage at trapping site – Photo by Luca Eberle


























