In an open letter to new EU President Juncker, Green10 NGOs operating at a European level have sharply criticised his decision to nominate a Maltese Commissioner with responsibilities for the environment. Regarding this decision, the letter states:

“The inclusion in the mandate of orders to consider changing the EU Nature protection legislation, pre-empting the results of the ongoing fitness check, suggests a high level decision to weaken biodiversity protection in the EU. This is even more troubling as the Environment portfolio is given to a Commissioner whose government is under intense international criticism for failing to implement EU bird conservation legislation, which the Commissioner will now be in position to amend.”

While critical of many of the other proposals made by the new President, it is the new environment and portfolio that comes under the closest scrutiny.

BirdLife Malta Executive Director, Steve Micklewright said, “the NGOs that have signed this letter are experts in European policy. Their analysis seems to be that the proposed new Maltese Commissioner will be responsible for weakening environmental protection across Europe. This open letter is clearly the start of a campaign across Europe to ensure that does not happen.”

In particular the Green10 said in the letter that they are concerned that:

• The move from a Commissioner with dedicated responsibilities for environment to having this policy area shared with other demanding dossiers represents a clear relegation of environmental issues in the order of political priorities. This is reinforced by the virtual lack of any reference to environment in the responsibilities of the Vice-Presidents.

• The mandate to the Environment, Maritime Affairs and Fisheries Commissioner seems entirely centred on deregulation, asking a review of all current major initiatives underway. It does not mention the need to achieve any EU objectives, let alone take new initiatives.

• The inclusion in the mandate of orders to consider changing the EU Nature protection legislation, pre-empting the results of the ongoing fitness check, suggests a high level decision to weaken biodiversity protection in the EU. This is even more troubling as the Environment portfolio is given to a Commissioner whose government is under intense international criticism for failing to implement EU bird conservation legislation, which the Commissioner will now be in position to amend.

• The merging of the climate and energy portfolios and putting this Commissioner under a Vice President for Energy Union could imply that Climate Action is considered subordinate to energy market considerations.

• The choice of a Climate and Energy Commissioner with well-known links to the fossil fuel industry raises issues of conflict of interest.

• The shift of the responsibility for relations with the European Chemicals Agency, whose job is to protect European citizens from harmful chemicals, from DG Environment to DG Enterprise shows a clear bias towards prioritising business interests over protection of human health and the environment and flies in the face of the objectives of the REACH Regulation.

• The fact that sustainable development, resource efficiency and the green economy are not covered at all at Vice-President level implies a Commission that will be operating on the basis of an outdated paradigm of economic growth, one that benefits the industries and jobs of the past over those of the future, and detached from real world constraints and limits.

• Your promise not to authorise any legislative initiative that is not in line with your priorities, combined with the virtual absence of any environmental priorities, suggests a de-facto shut down of EU environmental policy making.

The Green 10 NGOs are: BirdLife Europe, Climate Action Network (CAN) Europe, CEE Bankwatch Network, European Environmental Bureau, Friends of the Earth Europe, Greenpeace European Unit, Health & Environment Alliance, Naturefriends International, The European Federation for Transport and Environment (T&E), WWF European Policy Office

Permalink: Green10 NGOs in an open letter criticise new European Commissioner