Annual audit report for 2007 shows a number of issues to be addressed

Email item Email item Print item Print item

The Auditor General has presented the Annual Audit Report for 2007. It identifies a number of issues that need to be addressed by responsible entities so as to ensure better use of public funds and an enhanced service delivery.

Following the examination of the Financial Report 2007, amongst others, NAO noted that:

· analysis of variations, between budgeted and actual amounts for 2007, needs to be improved at Ministerial and Departmental levels;

· transactions dated 2008 were incorrectly reported in the 2007 Financial Year;

· debenture interest and loan repayments recorded as received from a public corporation were effectively paid by Government;

· the completeness of reporting of the Statement of Investments and Statement of Abandoned Claims, Cash Losses and Stores written off could not be ensured; and

· the Public Account for the period June 1992 – December 2001, as shown in Treasury Books and those of the Central Bank of Malta, has not yet been reconciled.

A number of Ministries, Departments and Entities failed to send their annual 2007 Return of Arrears to the Treasury.

Shortcomings were identified over the checking conducted by the Salaries Section within the Ministry for Gozo prior to issuing of Salaries service-wide. Lack of controls over duties and work performed by part-time Consultants/Advisers employed with various Ministries was also noted.

The Travel Abroad on Official Government Business report makes reference to various Ministry of Finance’s Circulars related to travel abroad, in particular MFIN Circular 1/2008, issued on the basis of conclusions and recommendations put forward in Reports of the Auditor General.

A number of concerns arose when an audit of the Social Security Contributions – Class I (Post 1998) – was carried out at the Inland Revenue Department. In particular it was noted that:

· enforcement measures need to be urgently introduced to ensure collection of the amounts of Social Security outstanding;

· there is lack of proper monitoring ensuring compliance with settlement agreements; and

· the Department is not in a position to quantify the amounts due by employers.

From a review of the audit reports and the relative management letters submitted by Local Government auditors for all Local Councils, a number of concerns were raised relating to lack of accountability especially as regards the management of public funds by a number of Councils.

No Joint Committees’ audit reports were available by the time the audit of the Local Councils was carried out. Presently there is no legislation regulating the submission of the Joint Committees’ financial statements. Although nine Local Councils had a change in their Executive Secretary during the year, only two mid-term audits have been carried out.

The present facility incorporated in the weapons systems managed by the Police Department needs to be enhanced so as to eliminate old balances, including those reported in the return of arrears of revenue of licences.

An IT Audit held at the Courts of Justice and the Education Division involved the Entity Level Controls and Business Continuity planning with respect to IT. These audits sought to determine whether an adequate strategy defined the auditees’ IT direction and whether information management and processing was set down in policies and procedures. The Courts of Justice’s IT planning with respect to business continuity in the event of disruptions due to a disaster was also evaluated. The IT Audits identified a considerable need for improvement in the planning of both areas. The IT Strategy planning and Business Continuity planning processes at the Education Division need to be strengthened.

An audit at the Education Division revealed that the School Transport Section (STS) lacked segregation of duties. Lack of controls in the system resulted in overpayments; moreover, shortcomings in the contract of service were also noted. The budget for the provision of School Transport was exceeded.

Procurement of routes in connection with ‘Special’ School Transport for students in the mainstream schools was not always effected in accordance with standing procurement regulations. The service provider, who was awarded the new contract, continued to invoice the Education Division with the rates of the previous contract which were higher.

Log books reviewed during an audit of the Transport Pool at the Education Division showed that vehicles were being retained by the officers after office hours.

IT network accessories meeting the criteria of tangible fixed assets were not included in the inventory records of the Ministry for Gozo. Audit trail of a number of other items purchased in 2006, from the budget cost centre of the Ministry on behalf of other Departments, was also lacking in the inventory records. It was also noted that 11% of the total inventory value reported by the Department of Corporate Services was damaged.

Various issues of concern were raised during an audit at the Licensing and Testing Directorate. These related mostly to the registration of new vehicles including those which are entitled to either a discount or exemption in registration tax.

A lack of periodical review of files in respect of Sickness Assistance benefits was encountered in an audit carried out at the Social Security Department.

Segregation of duties at the Maltese Embassy in Paris was lacking. Completeness of revenue collected on behalf of Government could not be confirmed mainly due to lack of source documentation. Administrative guidelines issued by the Head Office to the Maltese Missions abroad need to be reviewed.

The Central Liaison Office (CLO) has a direct access through the computerised VAT Information Exchange System (VIES) to the VAT registration database of the Member States. Shortcomings over the control of Recaps statements, their keying-in and reconciliation thereof were noted.

A follow-up performance audit revealed that the most significant development since the publication of the report Acquisition of Property by Government in 2004, related to the Lands Acquisition Ordinance (LAO) amendments which streamlined the lands’ acquisition process. However, outstanding dues in respect of acquisitions dating back before the 2003 amendments to the LAO continue to pose serious challenges. The acquisitions function is still not adequately supported with a reliable management information system, and sufficient documented policies and guidelines.

An audit carried out at the Police Department on Salaries revealed a number of weaknesses, including incorrect computation of income supplement, bonuses and sick leave. This is mainly due to the fact that adjustments to payroll are still being calculated manually prior to submission to Treasury.

The full report can be viewed as from tomorrow, the 16th of December 2008, on the NAO website at http://www.nao.gov.mt.

  • Permalink: Annual audit report for 2007 shows a number of issues to be addressed
  • You may also like...

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *