Update – Court revokes injunction on Turtle-dove hunting in spring

Update – Court revokes injunction on Turtle-dove hunting in spring
Email item Email item Print item Print item

Update by Gozo Minister and FKNK below – BirdLife Malta has said that in a decision announced this morning, the Court revoked the Warrant of Prohibitory Injunction against Turtle-dove hunting in spring which was provisionally accepted earlier this week.

The decree was given by Madame Justice Audrey Demicoli following a hearing which was held yesterday in Court.

In a statement BirdLife said that, the Court accepted the Government’s argument that the season cannot be suspended due to the fact that Legal Notice 116 of 2022 allowing the spring hunting derogation has already been issued and is already in force.

The Court also decreed that there “weren’t sufficient reasons to stop the spring hunting season on Turtle-dove.”

BirdLife Malta stated that this is “effectively accepting the Government’s reasoning that there was no evidence that Turtle-dove numbers are on the decrease, despite the fact that the endangered species is listed as Vulnerable to Extinction by the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species, with a number of countries also halting its hunting in autumn, let alone in spring.”

“Unfortunately the 2022 spring hunting season on the protected European Turtle-dove will proceed as planned,” BirdLife Malta said, hunting on this species will open this coming Sunday following the refusal by the Court of a request by BirdLife Malta to refer the case about the spring hunting of the Vulnerable European Turtle-dove to the European Court of Justice (ECJ) for an opinion.

Originally the hearing was appointed for Tuesday, the 19th of April, but in a last-ditch attempt to make sure that the case is urgently heard before the scheduled start of the Turtle-Dove hunting season in two days’ time, the Government filed a Court Application, through the State Advocate, requesting that the case is heard before the 19th.

In another Court Application in response to this, BirdLife Malta said that it then requested that the local Court refers the matter to the ECJ for guidance, given that BirdLife Malta maintains that asking for a Prohibitory Injunction to prevent a breach of the European Birds Directive is a right granted by EU law.

While the Court accepted the urgency request and brought forward the date of the hearing to yesterday at 9am, during the proceedings both BirdLife Malta through its legal team and the office of the State Advocate presented their arguments.

BirdLife said that although a request by the Federation for Hunting and Conservation (FKNK) – through another Court Application – to appear as party to the case was thrown out by the Judge, a strong presence of hunters could be observed in Court. At the end of the hearing Madame Justice Demicoli said she would decree in chambers.

Following this morning’s decision, BirdLife Malta said that it is “disappointed and also surprised that European law was not protected by the local Courts and that there are no means of having remedy to a breach of the European Directives – in this case the EU Birds Directive.”

BirdLife Malta President Darryl Grima and CEO Mark Sultana stated “we remain certain that we have the correct arguments with regards to the illegal spring hunting of the Vulnerable Turtle-dove.”

He concluded by saying that “the next legal actions and processes are in hand. In the meantime the European Commission now has more responsibility to act fast on this hunting season and we expect to see developments in this regard in the near future.”

Updates –

Gozo Minister Clint Camilleri

Writing on social media, Gozo Minister Clint Camilleri said, “what is ours, remains ours.”

“This morning the Court revoked the mandate of Birdlife Malta and did not grant their claims with the costs of these proceedings against BirdLife Malta, the Minister said.

He thanked the teams from the State Attorney’ office and WBRU, who, the Minister said, “worked day and night to revoke this injunction.”

He added, “the Turtle-dove hunting season opens on Sunday as planned.”

FKNK statement

Hunting federation FKNK welcomed “another historic victory” and expressed its “joy and satisfaction that justice has been done both in the context of science and in the interpretation of the law.”

Thanking its members for their continued support, FKNK wished all its licensed members a “good season,”’ and urged “absolute compliance with laws and regulations, including on reporting.”

Photo: BirdLife Malta

  • Permalink: Update – Court revokes injunction on Turtle-dove hunting in spring
  • You may also like...

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *