Planning Bills give unchecked power to PA and developers, but disempower the people – NGOs
Email item
| Print item
|
|
This evening, a number of organisations held a press conference in front of Parliament to call for the immediate withdrawal of the two “shocking” Bills presented by the Government last week.
These Bills aim to amend the Development Planning Act and the Environment and Planning Review Tribunal Act.
The organisations stated that while Prime Minister Robert Abela is attempting to present these Bills as the long-promised and much-needed reform of the appeals system, “in truth, these amendments go far beyond the appeals framework and will effectively dismantle existing safeguards in the planning legislative framework.”
They stressed that these new amendments to planning laws are “highly dangerous and represent a wishlist dictated by developers.”
“No wonder the government repeatedly refused to consult with NGOs and the public, instead presenting the Bills – already finalised – mid-summer,” said the organisations.
They emphasised that this is “not a partisan issue. In fact, many figures within the Labour Party are shocked by these amendments and do not agree with them.”
The organisations highlighted that among other measures, the proposed amendments will:
· Give the Planning Authority (PA) and the Minister for Planning the power to take arbitrary decisions at their sole discretion. As a result, existing rules and plans will be stripped of all legal authority. The PA and the Minister will be able to create new rules, issue new policies without consultation, depart from existing policies, regularise illegalities, alter permitted building heights and ODZ areas, and reactivate expired permits.
· Policies issued at the PA’s and Minister’s discretion will no longer be required to conform to Local Plans, meaning that anything can change overnight, since the law will begin to recognise only the most recently issued policy, disregarding all existing ones.
· Severely restrict the public’s right to appeal. The obstacles being introduced will make it nearly impossible for citizens to exercise their right since the appeal submission period is being cut to just 20 days, which is unrealistic; appeals must be based solely on legal points raised in the original objection; and appellants may be fined €5,000 if the Tribunal deems the appeal frivolous or unfounded, without the right to appeal this decision.
· The Courts will no longer be able to annul an irregular permit issued by the PA, and may only send the decision back to the Tribunal – a body lacking any independence. Moreover, if the Court fails to issue a judgement within five months, any construction carried out after that period can no longer be considered illegal.
The organisations stressed that these new laws, “which aim to dismantle entirely the existing legal structures that provide even minimal decency in the planning sector, will lead to disaster for the country and the future of our children.”
In light of this deeply troubling situation, the organisations reiterated their call for “the immediate withdrawal of these drafts and the initiation of a transparent and inclusive consultation process through a White Paper.”
The organisations are:
Azzjoni: Tuna Artna Lura
BirdLife Malta
Din l-Art Helwa
Flimkien ghal Ambjent Ahjar
Friends of the Earth Malta
Ghawdix
Moviment Graffitti
Nature Trust – FEE Malta
Ramblers Association
Wirt Ghawdex.
Photo: Moviment Graffitti


























